The Rapture - criticisms refuted
The
‘rapture’
is
an
event
at
some
time
in
the
future
when
Jesus
will
return
(not
His
second
coming)
to
remove
all
true
believers
from the earth before He unleashes God’s wrath on a fallen, unbelieving and rebellious world.
Is the event described as the rapture true or false?
Many deny the doctrine of the rapture with some saying:
It isn’t in the Bible
It wasn’t taught until the 19th century, or,
It is misrepresented and is simply part of the second coming of Christ.
This article addresses each of these concerns and shows how the rapture is taught in the New Testament
The rapture isn’t in the Bible
It is true the word rapture isn’t found in our English Bible. The text in question is 1Thess 4:13-18, of which verse 17 reads:
Then
we
who
are
alive
and
remain
shall
be
caught
up
together
with
them
in
the
clouds
to
meet
the
Lord
in
the
air.
And
thus we shall always be with the Lord.
The
words
caught
up
are
a
translation
of
the
Greek
word
harpazo
,
which
literally
means
“to
snatch
away”
or
“to
seize
by
force”.
In
the
Latin
Vulgate,
this
concept
is
translated
using
the
word
raptus
of
which
the
verb
form
is
rapturo
,
which
means
“to
seize”
or “carry off”, from where the English term rapture originates.
The word rapture isn’t in the Bible, but the event is.
The rapture wasn’t taught until the 19th century
According
to
Wikipedia:
“The
idea
of
a
rapture
as
it
is
defined
in
dispensational
premillennialism
is
not
found
in
historic
Christianity and is a relatively recent doctrine originating from the 1830s.”
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rapture
John
Nelson
Derby
is
said
by
many
to
be
the
father
of
modern
dispensationalism.
It
was
Darby
who
popularised
the
pre-
tribulation
rapture
theology
in
the
1830s
(
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Nelson_Darby
).
However,
several
early
church
fathers
wrote
about
the
rapture
(being
caught
up)
before
the
end
of
the
4th
century.
Some
examples
follow
with
relevant
words
in bold.
Irenaeus
(130–202
AD
)
A
disciple
of
Polycarp,
a
student
of
the
Apostle
John.
Irenaeus
later
became
bishop
of
the
church
in
Lyons,
France,
and
is
famous
for
his
five-volume
treatise,
“Against
Heresies”,
which
described
and
challenged
all
false
teaching
from
the
emerging
cults
of
his
day. He believed in a pre-tribulation rapture of the Church and in “Against Heresies” 5:29.1 he wrote:
“And
therefore,
when
in
the
end
the
Church
shall
be
suddenly
caught
up
(harpazo/raptured)
from
this,
it
is
said
(meaning,
follows
on
from
suddenly
caught
up
),
“There
shall
be
tribulation
such
as
has
not
been
since
the
beginning,
neither shall be. (
see Mat 24:21
)
”
For
this
is
the
last
contest
of
the
righteous,
in
which,
when
they
overcome
they
are
crowned
with
incorruption
.”
(see
1Cor 15:50, 53
)
Cyprian
(200–258
AD
)
Cyprian
was
Bishop
of
the
church
in
Carthage
during
intense
persecution
by
the
Roman
Empire.
In
258
AD
he
was
beheaded
for
his faith. Several of his works still exist today.
In his work “Treatise of Cyprian”, Chapter 7 Treatise VII, on the Mortality, he wrote:
26.
“We
should
consider,
dearly
beloved
brethren
--
we
should
ever
and
anon
reflect
that
we
have
renounced
the
world,
and
are
in
the
meantime
living
here
as
guests
and
strangers.
Let
us
greet
the
day
which
assigns
each
of
us
to
his
own
home,
which
snatches
us
(harpazo/rapture)
hence,
and
sets
us
free
from
the
snares
of
the
world
(during
the
tribulation),
and restores us to paradise and the kingdom.
Victorinus
Saint
Victorinus
was
bishop
of
the
Pannonian
city
of
Poetovio
(or
Pettavium;
now
the
modern
Ptui,
Slovenia)
in
the
second
half
of the third century.
In 240
AD
he authored a “Commentary On the Apocalypse” and was eventually martyred for his faith.
In the Fifteenth Chapter, he wrote:
“The
same
Apocalypse
repeats
the
persecution;
it
says:
Seven
angels
having
plagues,
because
with
these
the
wrath
of
God
is
finished.
For
the
wrath
of
God
always
struck
a
stubborn
people
with
seven
plagues,
that
is
perfectly,
as
it
says
in
Leviticus; (plagues) which will happen in the future, when the Church will have
gone out from their midst
(raptured).”
Ephraim
the Syrian of Nisibis (306-373
AD
)
Ephraem
was
a
prominent
Syrian
church
father
known
for
his
hymns
and
theological
writings.
In
his
work
"On
the
Last
Times,"
he
explicitly
stated
that
the
saints
would
be
gathered
before
the
tribulation,
indicating
a
belief
in
a
pre-tribulation
rapture.
He
urged believers to prepare for the coming of the Lord to escape the impending chaos.
In his work, “The Last Times”, Ephraim wrote:
“Believe
you
me,
dearest
brother,
because
the
coming
of
the
Lord
is
nigh,
believe
you
me,
because
the
end
of
the
world
is
at
hand,
believe
me,
because
it
is
the
very
last
time.
Or
do
you
not
believe
unless
you
see
with
your
eyes?
See
to
it
that
this sentence be not fulfilled among you of the prophet who declares:
“Woe to those who desire to see the day of the Lord!”
“For
all
the
saints
and
elect
of
God
are
gathered
(raptured),
prior
to
the
tribulation
that
is
to
come
,
and
are
taken
to the Lord lest they see the confusion that is to overwhelm the world because of our sins.”
These
writings
on
their
own
do
not
prove
the
existence
of
a
pre-tribulation
rapture,
nor
can
they
be
regarded
in
any
way
as
authoritative
as
Scripture.
They
do,
however,
clearly
demonstrate
that
the
teaching
of
a
pre-tribulation
rapture
is
not
a
“modern
invention” that supposedly began in the 1800s
The rapture is misrepresented and is simply part of the second coming of Christ
This chart provides an overview of why the rapture and the second coming are separate events.
RAPTURE
SECOND COMING
The
rapture
is
for
believers
only
(
John
14:1-3
),
who
will
meet
the
Lord
in
the
air
(
1Thes
4:17
)
in
like
manner
to
the
ascension (
Acts 1:9-11
).
Believers
will
already
be
in
heaven
with
the
Lord
and
return
with
Him
at
His
second
coming
(
Rev
19:14
;
Jude
14
)
when
the
Lord will come down to the earth (
Zech 14:4
).
The
meeting
with
the
Lord
will
be
in
an
instant
and
therefore
only visible to believers (
1Cor 15:51-52a
).
Will be visible to all (
Mat 24:30; Rev 1:7
).
Could take place at any moment (
1Thes 4:15; 1Cor 15:51
).
This
is
known
as
the
doctrine
of
imminence.
However,
I
believe
Daniel
9:27
contains
the
marker
but,
given
the
current
geopolitical
situation,
it
could
now
be
near
future,
but
not
necessarily.
Other
end-time
events
must
take
place
first
(
Mat
24:15
and
2Thes 2:3-4
).
After
the
tribulation
and
having
been
subjected
to
God’s
wrath
(
Dan 9:24; Rev 6-18
)
John 14:1-3
1 "Let not your heart be troubled; you believe in God, believe also in Me.
2
In
My
Father's
house
are
many
mansions;
if
it
were
not
so,
I
would
have
told
you.
I go to prepare a place for you.
3
And
if
I
go
and
prepare
a
place
for
you,
I
will
come
again
and
receive
you
to
Myself; that where I am, there you may be also.
In
these
verses
Jesus
is
talking
to
His
disciples,
and
by
extension
His
church,
which
is
us.
He
is
specifically
telling
us
He
will
return
for
us
to
take
us
to
a
place
prepared
for
us
in
heaven.
The
framework
of
this
message
is
the
Jewish
wedding
process
in
which,
once
all
the
terms
of
the
marriage
are
agreed
and
contracted,
the
bride
returns
to
her
home
to
prepare
for
her
wedding
day.
The
groom
returns
to
his
father's
house
to
prepare
their
marriage
home,
often
an
extension
to
his
father's
house.
It
is
then
the
father's
decision
as
to
when
all
is
ready
and
the
groom
is
sent
to
collect
his
bride
to
take
her
to
a
place
prepared
for
her.
The
disciples,
who
were
Jews,
would
have
recognised
this
analogy,
but
probably
not
yet
realised
Jesus
was
saying
He
is
the
groom
and
they
are
His
bride.
It
isn't
until
we
read
in
Ephesians
5:32 that Paul reveals this 'mystery'.
In
these
few
words
in
John
14:1-3,
Jesus
is
revealing
that
there
is
going
to
be
a
time
when
He
will
take
His
people
off
this
earth
to
be
with
Him
for
eternity.
The
realisation
that
this
is
an
event
that
only
involves
His
people,
believers,
tells
us
Jesus
is
describing the Rapture.
1Th 4:17
Then
we
who
are
alive
and
remain
shall
be
caught
up
together
with
them
in
the
clouds
to
meet
the
Lord
in
the air. And thus we shall always be with the Lord.
Act 1:9-11
9
Now
when
He
had
spoken
these
things,
while
they
watched,
He
was
taken
up,
and
a
cloud
received
Him
out
of
their sight.
10
And
while
they
looked
steadfastly
toward
heaven
as
He
went up, behold, two men stood by them in white apparel,
11
who
also
said,
"Men
of
Galilee,
why
do
you
stand
gazing
up
into
heaven?
This
same
Jesus,
who
was
taken
up
from
you
into
heaven,
will
so
come
in
like
manner
as
you
saw
Him
go into heaven.
Rev 19:14
And
the
armies
in
heaven,
clothed
in
fine
linen,
white and clean, followed Him on white horses.
“clothed
in
fine
linen,
white
and
clean”
is
the
apparel of the saints.
Jude 14
Now
Enoch,
the
seventh
from
Adam,
prophesied
about
these
men
also,
saying,
"Behold,
the
Lord
comes
with
ten thousands of His saints,”
Zec 14:4
And
in
that
day
His
feet
will
stand
on
the
Mount
of
Olives,
Which
faces
Jerusalem
on
the
east.
And
the
Mount
of
Olives
shall
be
split
in
two,
From
east
to
west,
Making
a
very
large
valley;
Half
of
the
mountain
shall
move
toward
the
north
And
half
of
it
toward
the
south.
1Co 15:51-52a
51
Behold,
I
tell
you
a
mystery:
We
shall
not
all
sleep,
but
we shall all be changed—
52a in a moment, in the twinkling of an eye
Visible to all
Mat
24:30
Then
the
sign
of
the
Son
of
Man
will
appear
in
heaven,
and
then
all
the
tribes
of
the
earth
will
mourn,
and
they
will
see
the
Son
of
Man
coming
on
the
clouds
of
heaven
with power and great glory.
Rev
1:7
Behold,
He
is
coming
with
clouds,
and
every
eye
will
see
Him,
even
they
who
pierced
Him.
And
all
the
tribes
of
the
earth will mourn because of Him. Even so, Amen.
‘Coming
on
the/with
clouds’
is
before
the
Lord
comes
down
on
the Mount of Olives (Zech 14:4 above)
1Thes 4:15; 1Cor 15:51
1Thes
4:15
For
this
we
say
to
you
by
the
word
of
the
Lord,
that
we
who
are
alive
and
remain
until
the
coming
of
the
Lord
will by no means precede those who are asleep.
1Co
15:51
Behold,
I
tell
you
a
mystery:
We
shall
not
all
sleep, but we shall all be changed -
Mat
24:15
"Therefore
when
you
see
the
'abomination
of
desolation,'
spoken
of
by
Daniel
the
prophet,
standing
in
the
holy place" (whoever reads, let him understand),
2Th
2:3-4
Let
no
one
deceive
you
by
any
means;
for
that
Day
will
not
come
unless
the
falling
away
comes
first,
and
the
man
of
sin
is
revealed,
the
son
of
perdition,
who
opposes
and
exalts
himself
above
all
that
is
called
God
or
that
is
worshiped,
so
that
he
sits
as
God
in
the
temple
of
God,
showing himself that he is God.
These
are
referring
to
Daniel’s
70th
week
which
precedes
the
second coming (Rev 19)
Before God’s wrath
1Th
5:9
For
God
did
not
appoint
us
to
wrath,
but
to
obtain
salvation through our Lord Jesus Christ,
Rev
3:10
Because
you
have
kept
My
command
to
persevere,
I
also
will
keep
you
from
the
hour
of
trial
which
shall
come
upon the whole world, to test those who dwell on the earth.
After being subjected to God’s wrath
Dan
9:24
"Seventy
weeks
are
determined
For
your
people
and
for
your
holy
city,
To
finish
the
transgression,
To
make
an
end
of
sins,
To
make
reconciliation
for
iniquity,
To
bring
in
everlasting
righteousness,
To
seal
up
vision
and
prophecy,
And to anoint the Most Holy
.
The
angel
Gabriel
tells
Daniel
that
this
‘seventy
week’
prophecy
is
for
“your
people”,
that
is,
Israel.
Because
the
Jews
didn’t
accept
Jesus
as
their
Messiah,
the
seventieth
‘week’,
the
final
seven
years,
is
the
period
during
which
they
will
come
to
acknowledge
Him:
Mat
23:39
for
I
say
to
you,
you
shall
see
Me
no
more
till
you
say,
'Blessed
is
he
that
comes in the name of the Lord!'
Rev
6-18
There
is
no
mention
of
the
church
after
the
Lamb
(Jesus)
receives
the
seven-seal
scroll
(chapter
5),
until
the
Marriage Supper of the Lamb in chapter 19.
Matthew 24:21
For
then
there
will
be
great
tribulation,
such
as
has
not
been
since
the
beginning
of
the
world until this time, no, nor ever shall be.
1Co 15:50 Now this I say, brethren, that flesh and
blood cannot inherit the kingdom of God; nor does
corruption inherit incorruption.
1Co 15:53 For this corruptible must put on
incorruption, and this mortal must put on immortality.